Virginia Tech leads this week’s Misery Index after a 41-36 loss to Syracuse. Here are the others that made the index, a weekly measurement of knee-jerk reactions based on what each fan base just watched:
FOUR MORE IN MISERY
Colorado State: Steve Addazio didn’t bother to hire a special teams coach for the Rams when he was hired a couple years ago, choosing to handle some of those duties himself. Which makes Colorado State’s 26-24 loss to Utah State on Friday a double-whammy of incompetence that can be laid right at Addazio’s feat since both the person responsible for managing the clock and the person responsible for the field-goal unit totally melted down with the game on the line.
After Colorado State got a first down with 12 seconds left and the ball on the 24-yard line, the obvious next play was for the quarterback to line up, spike it and have a full play clock for the field-goal team to set up for a game-winning kick. The Rams were not pleased with the situation. Instead, the field-goal team ran onto the field trying to snap a shot in a hurry as the clock ticked down to zero. During this time, offensive players had no choice but to sprint off the field. There was also a lot of shifting with the offensive line before everyone finally got on their feet. It was not a team that looked confident or ready to make the crucial play. The kick was missed badly by the Rams, who fell to 3-4.
Addazio, who got the job at CSU largely because Urban Meyer recommended him, has had clock management issues before — notably in 2015 when his Boston College team ran out of time near the goal line because it tried to run the ball into the end zone rather than pass it with no timeouts left and fewer than 20 seconds to work with.
Colorado State fans and players deserved better than what they got Friday night. It shouldn’t have come as a surprise, given Addazios past in such situations.
WEEK 8 REPORT CARD: Mississippi State’s Mike Leach earns an ‘A’ for great candy takes
Penn State: As a fan, if you’re going to lose to a team like Illinois, you’d rather it happen like a maximum-strength band-aid being pulled off a hairy leg. It’s easy to know how it will feel, to prepare for the pain and to know that it will be over soon. But for the Nittany Lions, it was impossible to know when their 20-18 loss to Illinois was going to end or how frustrating the process of getting there might be. Even worse, the NCAA’s terrible gimmicks did not make the game unfair. Penn State, which had just 227 offensive yards, absolutely deserved to fall to 5-2.
The only thing that made this game notable was the use of the new overtime procedure where the regular possessions from the 25-yard line end after the second overtime and the teams just attempt two-point conversions until there’s a score and a stop (or a stop and score) to end the game. This was supposed to prevent teams from having to play multiple overtimes that could potentially pose a risk to player safety.
But this wasn’t an exciting finish. It was an exhausting grind as both teams failed to score on five of their first five two point conversion attempts. In the ninth overtime, Illinois finally got a stop and scored to end this terrible game.
Had this loss happened against a better opponent, Penn State fans might have been able to chalk it up to bad luck. With quarterback Sean Clifford clearly not himself (19-for-34, 165 yards) after suffering a rib/midsection injury two weeks ago against Iowa, generating offense was probably going to be dicey no matter what.
But if Penn State was as good of a program as coach James Franklin should have built by now, they could have withstood this one and bought more time for Clifford to get healthy. Fans were forced to witness one of the longest offensive nosedives in college football’s history.
Clemson: Over the past six years, the Tigers didn’t just upgrade their house, they bullied their way into the most exclusive neighborhood in the country. One of the most distinctive characteristics of this subdivision is its ability to have a low level of ups and downs. Some years are better than others for the Alabamas and Ohio States, Oklahomas and Oklahomas. Except for some very unusual circumstances, there is no drop in mediocrity.
With a 27-17 loss to Pitt, though, it’s fair to question whether Clemson’s program still belongs among the group that it worked so hard to join.
What we’re seeing from Clemson right now seems deeper than inexperience or the ball bouncing someone else’s way. Because the Tigers are currently 4-3, it’s a good indication of how strong they are in a weak ACC. Their across-the-board drop-off from the championship level they reached between 2015 and 2019 is palpable at nearly every position on the field. Their coaching lacks imagination and boldness. They are content with what they do, but it is easy to become complacent in a market where everything changes constantly.
“We are what we are right now,” coach Dabo Swinney told reporters. “We are very immature and young, and we have a very insecure offense.
Youth isn’t an excuse. Although both Alabama and Ohio State have had young teams, they don’t spiral as dramatically. Against six FBS opponents, Clemson has reached 20 points just once this year in a 27-21 loss to NC State. This should not happen if you recruit at the same level as the Tigers year after year.
It’s easy to pin a lot of the blame on sophomore quarterback D.J. Uiagalelei, who hasn’t developed as expected (12-for-25, 128 yards, two INTs) and was benched for a stretch against Pitt. Clemson has not shown much improvement since Week 1. This should indicate to their fans that it will take more than just a few tweaks to be back in contention for the national title.
TCU: Coach Gary Patterson’s defense mechanisms are working better than his actual defense these days, and it’s turning him into a somewhat embarrassing spectacle as he reaches the latter stages of a Hall of Fame career. After a dispute with SMU over post-game classlessness allegations, Patterson felt the need this week to pursue a TCU graduate named Matt Jennings. Jennings wrote a Medium blog post detailing the program’s many on-and off-field problems over the past few decades and arguing that it was time to make major changes.
Patterson wasn’t happy about the piece and spent several minutes of his weekly news conference steaming over its contents, even referring to himself in the third person at one point and sarcastically suggesting that Jennings should win a Pulitzer Prize.
“At the end of the day, those people out there that think I’m riding into the sunset would be wrong,” Patterson said.
But a grumpy, stubborn and vindictive Patterson isn’t doing much to help the real issue: With a 29-17 home loss against West Virginia, the Horned Frogs are 3-4 and in real danger of finishing below . 500 despite for the second time in three years. In fact, going back to 2016, TCU is just 38-31 — including an 11-win season.
So if we’re going to be as honest and direct as Patterson is with his players, it’s totally fair to say that the Horned Frogs have become a middling Big 12 program despite lots of assistant coaching changes, different approaches, returning starters and transfers brought in to fill holes.
It seems unlikely that Patterson’s job would be in trouble after 21 seasons, many of them crazy successful. For goodness sakes, there’s a statue of Patterson in front Amon G. Carter Stadium. Is he too old to be at TCU? Is he too comfortable, too strong, or too inflexible to adapt the game to modern players and games?
These are fair questions, not hot takes. These are not hot takes. Patterson is adamant about blaming others for asking them questions, but it’s clear that this fantastic run may end in a tumultuous way.
WINNERS AND LOSERS: Oregon escapes, Penn State falls out of playoff race
TRENDING TOWARD MISERY
Arizona: We need to start thinking about whether the Wildcats could end up as the worst offensive team of the last decade in college football. Not only did Arizona lose its 19th consecutive game on Friday against Washington, 21-16, but it continued its perfect record of failing to score 20 points under head coach Jedd Fisch. Whether it’s rolling up a lot of yards but committing five turnovers against Oregon, or blowing a 13-0 halftime lead over Washington, the result is the same. At this point, the Wildcats look like a good bet to lose at least 10 games in a season for the second time in school history.
Texas Tech: With a backloaded schedule that gets really tough right about now, the Red Raiders needed to bank as many wins as they could before Halloween to make the most out of this year and potentially give coach Matt Wells some breathing room before the fans start calling for his job. Instead, Texas Tech blew a 24-10 halftime lead against Kansas State and lost 25-24 at home to an opponent that had previously lost eight Big 12 games in a row. They did it with their offense scoring no points and gaining just 103 yards in the second half. They did it with their defense giving up 220 yards after halftime and bailing out Kansas State with a personal foul penalty on third-and-34 that ultimately led to the go-ahead touchdown with 6: 09 remaining. For Texas Tech fans, this is a familiar tale. This is a familiar story for Texas Tech fans. Wells has a record of 6-7 in games decided by fewer than a touchdown, with two wins against FCS teams. And at 7-16 in Big 12 games, Wells has a worse winning percentage in the league (30%) than predecessor Kliff Kingsbury (35%).
NC State: If you want to understand what a tortured existence it’s been for this fan base, consider that the last time the Wolfpack won an ACC title was 1979 — and they didn’t even get invited to a bowl game that year. This season was their best chance since the last one. They had already defeated Clemson to take the Atlantic Division lead. But after falling 31-30 at Miami, the Wolfpack is now one game behind Wake Forest in the loss column and the sense of “Same Ole NC State” has returned.
The Wolfpack was poised to get the ball back with more than two minutes left and a chance to let quarterback Devin Leary go win the game for them after he threw for 310 yards. Instead, NC State’s defense allowed Miami to convert a third-and-16 that effectively allowed the Hurricanes to run out the clock. The 5-2 record isn’t impressive for a team that was once hailed as one of the greatest under Dave Doeren.
UNLV: The Rebels got a nice pop of publicity last week for putting a large slot machine on the sideline for home games. The $60,000 piece of equipment, which was custom made by IGT, is bright and bold and certainly screams Las Vegas. UNLV would not want to attract any attention with its gimmicky props unless it wins at least one football game. The Rebels haven’t done that yet under Marcus Arroyo, who was hired on Dec. 11, 2019. That’s 0-13 to start a head-coaching career after this week’s 27-20 loss to San Jose State. If you want to spin it positively, UNLV’s past four losses are by a combined 26 points and they’ve had chances to win all those games. But until they close the deal, the slot machine represents the futility we’ve all felt in that town of putting in a $20 bill and watching it disappear in a matter of minutes.
UTEP: The Miners did not play this week, but they represent the angst of conference realignment leaving a program behind that doesn’t really deserve it. In the middle of their best season in years at 6-1, UTEP fans learned this week that six of Conference USA’s 14 programs are leaving for the American Athletic Conference and three others could be abandoning them for the Sun Belt. UTEP has a real fan base and an important part in the history of college sports, winning the 1966 NCAA basketball title as Texas Western with five Black starters against an all-white Kentucky team. They are a geographical outlier and have not been able form strong alliances or get any interest from the Mountain West. UTEP will need to continue to operate in a C-USA, which means that it is dependent on multiple schools to be able to compete at the FCS level. UTEP is celebrating a remarkable football turnaround in the past, but it must be concerned about the future.
TOTALLY REAL AND IRRATIONAL MESSAGE BOARD THREADS
“Envious of Wake Football…’nuff said” — techsideline.com (Virginia Tech)
“There are children who play Madden but understand clock management better.” — ramnation.com (Colorado State)
“Can you pick up a head coach through the portal?” — bluewhiteillustrated.com (Penn State)
“Pretty pumped about the Dukes Mayo bowl” — tigerillustrated.com (Clemson)
“Tear down the statue” — killerfrogs.com (TCU)